[Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Dragonstrike - 03-29-2020
Time for another pokerole adventure to begin, this time hosted by me!
Primal Shadows
Welcome to Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows!
For those of you who are returning players from the other Pokerole campaigns we've hosted on this forum, I hope you're ready for an experience unlike any other we've played so far!
And for those of you who are new players, welcome to the roleplay section (and possibly the forums as well)! We hope you'll enjoy your stay and have a lot of fun while you're here!
If you were a human who woke up as a pokemon one day, but had very little memory of your life from before you were a pokemon, what would you do? How would you survive? And more importantly, why were you turned into a pokemon in the first place? This campaign seeks to answer those questions and more, as we go on an adventure across the world of Pokemon Mystery Dungeon!
Current Players:
1. Lord Windos (Pyra the Devimp)
2. PhantomUnderYourDesk (Kee the Galarian Zigzagoon)
3. Spiritmon (Kogeki the Delta Riolu)
4. no one (Daxter the Midgardian Charmander)
Not currently looking for new players.
If there are empty spots in the list above, then we have room for new players to join the game! PM me if you'd like to join!
Do note that if you wish to join the game, it's expected that you'll be at least semi-active. Posting in the game thread every other day at minimum is ideal, but it's to be expected that real life will get in the way of that every so often. If and when something happens that interferes with your ability to play the game, inform the GM that you'll be unable to post if you can (and when you think you'll be able to resume posting if possible) so that they can take action accordingly. If you're inactive for long periods of time, the GM may auto your character or remove the character from the game at their discretion.
Character Creation, Rules, and Other Stuff
To get the ball rolling on actually joining the game, if you don't have the Pokerole rulebooks downloaded yet, the first thing you'll need to do is download and read through them. The first one you'll need is the corebook (we'll be using the 1.2.5 version, which is the latest one at the time of writing), and the second is the Pokerole Mystery Dungeon Module. Click this link to go to the Resources tab of the Pokerole website, where you can download both the corebook and the Mystery Dungeon Module.
Now then, whether you're new to Pokerole or a returning player on these forums, here's a brief overview of some rules and mechanics that are relevant to this game! If something has a page reference next to it and you want more information on the topic, you may want to read that section in the corebook or the Mystery Dungeon Module, starting on that specific page. (Of course, it's good to read all of the rules regardless, and I highly recommend doing so if you're unfamiliar with them, but this post should work as a quick reference if needed)
As with the other campaigns on this forum, all dice will be rolled by the GM in the interest of fairness. If I'm unable to roll physical dice, I'll roll digital ones online.
If you're new to Pokerole, here's how rolling the dice works:
- Most significant actions will require a pool of six sided dice to be rolled. How many dice are in that pool is determined by what action you are trying to perform, how many actions you're trying to perform, and what Attributes, Skills, and Specialties are related to those actions.
- Dice can be subtracted from your pool by move effects, statuses, or even just taking too much damage. If your dice pool for an action would become 0 or less, then the action will either fail automatically or a Luck Die will be rolled instead at the GM's discretion.
- A 4, 5, or 6 is a success, and a 1, 2, or 3 is a non-success. Two (1) results is a -1 success. For most tasks, you only need a single success for the action to succeed, though more complex tasks might need more successes at GM discretion. And generally, getting more successes means you do a better job of succeeding as well.
Generally, when I post the results of dice rolls, they'll look something like this:
Strength Check
(5)(2)(3) 1 success
These are dice from one of the official Pokemon TCG Elite Trainer Boxes. I'll probably be rolling a lot of these.
These stats are the core of the game, and are what make each pokemon unique compared to other species. These stats define what the character is good (or even excellent) at doing.
The Six Attributes
Health, Strength, Special, Dexterity, Defense, and Insight
There's six Attributes in my game, just like how there's six stats in the actual Pokemon games themselves. This differs a little from the base rules, so I'll be detailing the differences here.
- Strength, Special, and Dexterity work exactly like the book says they do. Strength corresponds to Attack, Special to Special Attack, and Dexterity to Speed.
- Health (HP) and Defense (Defense, obviously) both correspond to Vitality in the book, but are two separate stats instead of one in this game. Both of them have minimum and maximum values equal to the pokemon's listed Vitality stat in the corebook. There are cases where I may make special exceptions, however. Blissey is one of those possible exceptions, given their gargantuan HP stat is not represented very well in Pokerole's base rules at all.
- Insight corresponds to Special Defense, and is also partially related to your character's observational skills. In this game, if a character is hit by a Special Attack, the maximum damage of the move will be reduced by this stat instead of Defense. This is another departure from the base rules, but it should be easy enough to understand for anyone who's played the Pokemon games before.
As such, each pokemon species should be decent at performing well in the areas they usually do in the games. However, Attributes aren't the only stats that determine how well a character performs and what they excel at doing...
Every character has the same potential for leveling these various stats, and the maximum and minimum values are identical for everyone. These are the things that can be learned, rather than them being someone's innate potential, and that can be used to help shore up certain weak points, make strengths more effective, or even do things that are entirely unexpected! This is where most of the game's stat customization happens.
The Four Skills
Fight, Survival, Knowledge, and Contest
Each Skill covers a different area, and as such are used in different kinds of rolls. Each one also determines how skilled you are in each particular field.
The Countless Specialties
Specialties are extensions of Skills, and cover a wide range of categories. They're the cheapest stat to level up with the exp you've earned, but they cannot exceed the value of their corresponding Skill. If you aren't very good at Fighting, then you're probably not very good at Brawling or using Weapons either.
Highly Skilled characters with carefully honed Attributes and Specialties are rare, but they make for some of the most fearsome opponents and allies!
Social Attributes are used for a fair few Accuracy rolls (such as for Growl, which can use Tough or Cute), but they also play a large role in various social interactions. Whether you're trying to fit in with or leave a lasting impression on the townsfolk, persuade someone your idea is good or strike a bargain with Kecleon Wares to get a lower price on an item, how well that works out for you will usually be dependent on a roll involving a Social Attribute, the Contest Skill, and a Specialty related to the Contest Skill.
Generally, Social Rolls will show up when you're attempting to do a significant social interaction of some sort with one or more NPCs, but it's something to keep in mind since previous games on this forum didn't use the Social Attributes at all.
Accuracy Rolls involving a Social Attribute also have a special rule: due to the Social nature of the moves using them, they cannot be Evaded. This makes them particularly useful for weakening tough opponents!
Everyone is different, and how they interact with others and react to their surroundings will vary wildly. This classroom is in absolute chaos, no?
Pokedex (Page 83 of the corebook)
Every Pokemon from Gen 1-7 has stats in the corebook. If you need information on a pokemon not in the corebook, ask the GM.
Move Listings (Page 298 of the corebook)
Information on every move from Gen 1-7, not including Plot Deviced moves. Make sure to read the beginning of this section so you have an idea of what all the icons in the book mean. If you need information on a move not in the corebook, ask the GM.
Ability Listings (Page 371 of the corebook)
Information on every Ability from Gen 1-7, not including Plot Deviced Abilities. If you need information on an ability not in the corebook, ask the GM.
Recruiting Pokemon
After your characters have settled into living life as a pokemon, they may be presented with opportunities to convince NPC pokemon to join their group. Generally, this is resolved with a skill check opposing the NPC's Will score. The skill check that your character has to make depends on how they're trying to recruit the pokemon, though. Regardless of the method, it will usually involve one of the character's Social Attributes, the Contest stat, and one of the Contest Specialties. Whether you're friendly and inviting or tough and demanding, there's many different ways to recruit pokemon when the opportunity presents itself.
If an NPC is successfully recruited, the GM will keep track of their stats and any experience and items they gain. And on that note, depending on how you persuade the NPC to join your group, they may not lose any happiness or loyalty upon joining, either!
NPC pokemon will grow stronger on their own, but players can potantially influence an NPC's growth a little by interacting with them (such as by helping them train or giving them advice).
So many friends, so little time!
Surprises
The Surprise system used in the other games will be present. However, it is not replacing the Overtraining mechanic (Page 71 of the corebook).
A Surprise can be anything from a Shiny pokemon to a simple increase in a stat's maximum value. Later in the game, you'll be able to spend large amounts of exp to give your player characters Surprises as well and make them truly unique.
Three stats define how pokemon-like and human-like your character is in this game: Logic, Instinct, and Primal.
These stats are a big, big deal for your human character turned pokemon. Logic is related to your human memories, Instinct is related to your abilities as a pokemon, and Primal is the true beast within.
- High Logic scores allow your character to recall more of their human life and craft more and more complex tools. Simply put, you become more and more human-like the higher this score gets! However, if this stat ever becomes 0, you may have to create a new character since they won't be able to remember that they were human in the first place. It may be possible to help someone who's forgotten they were human remember who they are if they haven't completely become a feral pokemon, but it'll likely be a long, difficult process...
- High Instinct allows your character to use more of their pokemon species's move without having to spend exp to learn them. You can still spend exp to permanently learn a move regardless of what your current Instinct stat value is. In general, though, the better this stat is, the stronger you've become as a pokemon.
- And high Primal...well, the higher your primal is, the closer you are to becoming a feral pokemon, and the larger the penalties become for fainting. It goes without saying, but try not to faint too often.
- Humans turned into pokemon have to balance their Logic and Instinct and avoid losing themselves to the call of their Primal instincts. If they faint while their Primal score is 5, then the feral pokemon within takes over completely. In the event that happens, you'll likely have to create a new character.
- Increasing Logic decreases Instinct, and whenever Primal increases, Logic decreases. It's possible to be both Logical and Instinctual, but you have to work really hard at it!
- You might receive or lose points in any of the 3 stats at GM discretion depending on your role playing, and points awarded or taken away in this manner might not affect the other stats at GM discretion. You can also spend experience if you want to manually increase or decrease the three stats (though it costs 50 exp per point added/removed).
If there are currently available spots for new players (see the above Current Players list or talk to me, the GM), then this is how you'll go about creating a character to play as so you can join us!
As this is a Mystery Dungeon campaign, Character Creation is VERY different from a standard campaign by virtue of your character being a pokemon. As a result, a couple changes to what information needs to be filled out are required. Here's a few steps to follow for character creation:
Step 0: Ask the GM if you can join the game in a Private Message. This is a very important step. Please don't skip it.
Step 1: Create your character's human personality and backstory. Refer to Page 18 of the 1.2.5 Corebook for the relevant questions for creating a human character's personality and backstory for this PMD style game.
Step 2: Pick a pokemon with 3 base HP that is able to evolve and fits the character's personality. Your character will become that pokemon in the game. You can check a pokemon's base HP in the corebook's pokedex on Page 83. You can also choose to play as pokemon that fit the general criteria that aren't in the corebook (such as ones from Gen 8 or Delta Species), but you'll have to discuss that with the GM if you wish to do so.
Step 3: Discuss the character's backstory and pokemon choice with the GM. This is an important step since elements from the character's backstory may appear in the game, and the GM may have additional information regarding the pokemon they're becoming (such as additional level up moves or the creation of a custom pokemon). The GM will also give you a list of Level Up moves to refer to later in the character creation process and during the game itself (this particular step is also very important).
Step 4: Make a copy of the character sheet, which you can find here, and send the GM (me) a link with edit permissions in a PM via the Forums or Discord. Once you've made a copy of it and sent me that link, then you can start editing it.
Step 5: Determine what your starting Attribute values are and fill them in on the character sheet. Your starting Attributes and the initial limits on them are determined by what Pokemon Species your character starts as. Check the corebook's pokedex (which starts on Page 83) to determine what they are. If the pokemon is not in the corebook (due to being from Uranium, Gen 8, etc.) discuss it with the GM.
Step 6: Determine what your character's Social Attribute values are. They should all start out equal to their equivalent Attributes' values, with the exception of one Social Attribute of your choosing that fits your character's personality. That SA you choose gets a permanent +1 bonus.
Step 7: You get 3 free points to distribute to your Skills how you see fit at the start of the game. Dump all three into one Skill, or spread them between 2 or 3 Skills instead. The choice is yours.
Step 8: Adjust your character's Level according to how you distributed your free Skill Points. One Point each in three different Skills is a starting level of 4 (1+1+1+1=4), 2 Points in one Skill and 1 in a second starts you at Level 5 (1+1+2+1=5), and all three points in one Skill starts your character at Level 7 (1+1+2+3=7).
Step 9: Add 1 point to either Logic OR Instinct so that it has a starting value of 2 instead of 1. Pick only one. Higher Logic means you remember more of your human life, higher Instinct means you're able to use more Pokemon Moves without having to spend exp to learn them.
Step 10: Determine which moves your character is able to use, find them in the book (or ask the GM for details on the move if it isn't in the book), and write them down on the character sheet in the relevant tabs. If you have 1 Instinct, you can initially only use moves that cost 0 exp. If you have 2 Instinct, you can use moves that cost 10 exp or less for the pokemon species your character is.
Step 11: Follow any additional instructions the GM gives you. The prior 10 steps are just for creating the base stats for the character. If I have other information for you to add to the character sheet, it's likely so that you're character will be comparable to the existing players'.
And once that's finished, you should be ready to play! The GM will tag you in a post in the Game Thread when it's time to introduce your character in game!
Welcome to the world of pokemon! ...literally!
This being the world of Mystery Dungeon, there's a whole boatload of new items, most of which aren't in the world of pokemon trainers. You can find a list of some commonly used healing and food items in the character sheet's Storage tab (which will be important in the game later on), but here's a few examples of some of them:
- You'll be using Oran Berries instead of Potions, Tiny Reviver Seeds instead of Revives, all sorts of strange and wondrous orbs and apparel that would normally be mundane objects with no special powers...the list is rather large. Expect items to be a big part of your adventures, and for me to detail what new items that aren't listed in the book do when you discover them! Good note taking is highly advised!
- Your inventory space when going on adventures is also limited, unlike in the prior campaigns run on these forums. You'll need to find, earn, create, or purchase larger bags and other storage containers if you wish to carry more stuff.
A Wonder Orb, an item that holds one of a great many strange and powerful effects.
Food Items
It isn't a Mystery Dungeon game without a Hunger system of some sort! Well, it can happen, but Gates to Infinity ended up being a lot easier without that mechanic. Regardless, there will be a need to eat in this game!
- Apples are a food source, not a currency. Expect to go hungry if you don't bring food on your adventures. And if that happens, expect that to negatively affect your performance in battle, too! Fortunately, standard apples are sufficient for short trips, but you'll need either a lot of them or more filling foods if you're expecting to go on longer adventures!
- Every pokemon can eat Apples, but not all food is fruit! There's more food than you might expect in the PMD universe, including some that might seem a little out of place at first glance. Apples just happen to be the most common food source.
The namesake of the series, Mystery Dungeons are filled with twists and turns and all sorts of surprises. Not even I know what you'll find in them 100% of the time!
There are two types of Mystery Dungeons in this campaign: pre-generated and random.
- Pre-generated dungeons are created beforehand by me. Usually, these dungeons are going to be very important whenever they pop up. They could be made of preset tiles, or they might be a flowchart styled dungeon!
- Random dungeons, however, are another beast entirely. I have a physical deck of cards with basic dungeon layouts printed on them (courtesy of the MD Module), and I'll draw from it to determine what the next room is, and roll some dice to determine if you encounter anything in rooms as you enter them. It wouldn't be a Mystery Dungeon game without an element of random map generation, right?
- Generally, when you're exploring dungeons made from the tiles, I'll be providing and editing a Google Sheets doc that you can check to see a basic map of the dungeon at any time.
- To speed up the pace of the game, every room in a random dungeon will have a roll for a potential event. This differs from the base rules in the MD Module, but I feel it's a necessary change for the game to flow better on the forums. An event every other tile would feel too slow and drag the game out unnecessarily. There's still a chance for nothing to happen on any given tile, of course, but the increased event frequency should help keep things more exciting!
It's not a Pokerole Mystery Dungeon, but it's just as filled with random layouts, traps, wild encounters, and other miscellaneous events. Be prepared for anything.
Encounters are not as large of an issue in a Mystery Dungeon based system as they are in a standard Pokemon Trainer styled one. Everyone should be working together as a team, ideally, so there won't be a large need to determine who gets dibs on what besides the item loot (which is similar to what happens in Dungeons and Dragons and the like).
However, for some portions of this game, I'll still be using the encounter system we've set up. There may be times when there are many things that can be investigated or dealt with simultaneously and separately, and those are the kinds of situations that would warrant the use of the encounter system that Iron devised.
As an example, maybe you need to search a house for clues or evidence. I could list various points of interest as separate 'encounters' that can be resolved simultaneously, like so:
1. Bedroom
A straw bed, a nightstand, and a large rug are this room's most notable features.
2. Storeroom
No telling what might be in here unless you go open the door and look!
3. Garden
Is made up of flowers of many different colors.
4. Downstairs
Stairs that lead to the basement. It's pitch black down there.
By contrast, if the whole group gets attacked by a swarm of pokemon while traveling through a Mystery Dungeon, everyone's likely going to be involved, alleviating the need for separate encounters until the battle is finished.
When and where the Encounter system will be used is up to GM discretion, but the aim is for it to be utilized whenever it would make sense to mostly/entirely separate individual encounters from each other mechanically.
This does, however, mean that there won't be a static three encounters per day like there are in prior games on this forum. That doesn't change the fact that the GM will notify everyone when a new day has dawned, though!
Please read this whole section in the book if you aren't familiar with how Pokerole's combat works already.
Battles are much the same as in the previous campaigns. You give a set of orders for a round, accounting for any pain penalties and effects your character is experiencing, maybe set some conditional orders, and then see how everything plays out.
For those who are familiar with the games we've played on this forum already, however, there's one major change in this campaign: since we're using all the stats listed in the book, we're using all the accuracy pools for moves listed in the core book as is. Dexterity is no longer going to be the be-all end-all stat for both accuracy and initiative, and Fight isn't going to replace unusable stats. You'll have to be a little more diverse in how you spread out exp to buff your accuracy pools, but you won't have to pour most of your exp into two very specific stats if you want half-decent accuracy.
Oh, and since you're actually directly participating in the combat regularly this time around, getting KOed is a rather large danger for obvious reasons. There's a dearth of ways to avoid it, but they either have a monetary cost, are rarely found, or have some sort of drawback due to their ease of accessibility...
There's also going to be special battle mechanics later down the line, such as Mega Evolution. Yes, there's no pokemon trainers, but there are other ways to access that power and others like it...
Pain Penalties reduce your dice pools, and how much Pain you're in is determined by how much HP you've lost. Only the largest Pain Penalty is applied at any given time.
No Pain: At full HP or missing only 1 HP
-1 Pain: lost 2 or more HP
-2 Pain: at half HP or less
-3 Pain: have exactly 1 HP remaining
If you're in a great deal of pain, it's also usually difficult to escape from battle. Fortunately, healing items exist to make your life easier! Since this is a Mystery Dungeon style game, there's three primary healing items, and they're all rather effective:
Oran Berries: Restore 4 HP
Sitrus Berries: Restore 8 HP
Energy Seeds: Restore All HP
However, some wounds are too severe to heal them very easily. It takes 2 HP of healing to heal 1 point of Lethal damage. There are potential exceptions to this rule, but they're few and far between.
There's a wide range of status healing items, too.
Cheri Berry: Cures Paralysis
Pecha Berry: Cures Poison
Rawst Berry: Heals Burns
Chesto Berry: Cures Sleep
Aspear Berry: Defrosts Pokemon
Persim Berry: Cures Confusion
Lum Berry: Cures all of the above Status conditions
Heal Seed: Cures all Status Conditions, including ones a Lum Berry cannot cure
Make sure you have a healthy supply of Pecha Berries when you're expecting to face Poison types, as Poison can become deadly very, very quickly.
Generally, Seeds are going to have more powerful effects than Berries, but Berries will be more common. Speaking of Seeds, an adventurer's best friend in Mystery Dungeons is these two:
Tiny Reviver Seed: Revives a fainted pokemon with half HP. Does so automatically if it's in the pokemon's inventory when they faint, and becomes a Plain Seed when used in this manner.
Reviver Seed: Revives a fainted pokemon with full HP. Does so automatically if it's in the pokemon's inventory when they faint, and becomes a Plain Seed when used in this manner.
This is where I'll list anything that doesn't fit in the above categories, such as some houserules and important clarifications on rules. You may want to write at least a few of these down in your own notes.
This list is subject to change in the future, and I'll make a post in this Meta Thread detailing any changes that are made when they happen.
Houserules
- Assurance Move: changed its effect to '+3 damage dice if the target is at half HP or less' to better reflect the move's original purpose. It also just so happens that Assurance works a lot like Brine in the PMD games.
- Razor Shell Move: Effect changed to 'Roll 5 Chance Dice to reduce the foe's Defense by 1' to better reflect the move's original effect in the main series pokemon games.
- Illuminate Ability: Added the effect 'the user becomes a decoy (as if they had used Follow Me) whenever they use a light based attack (such as Confuse Ray)'. This is an effect the Ability has in the PMD games, and I think it'll work well in Pokerole!
- Reviver Seed Effectiveness: Changed both types of Reviver Seeds' so they function more like Revives in the main series Pokemon games with some of the automatic functionality they have in the PMD games.
- Healing Item Effectiveness: Oran Berries and Sitrus Berries heal more HP than what's stated in the corebook, as they are the common healing items in the PMD universe.
- Currency Shift: Poke is the currency this game is using, not Apples. The GM will determine what every item's cost is as appropriate.
- Encounter Frequency: To better fit the pacing of a forum based play-by-post game, a chance for encounters to appear will be rolled for every tile in a tile based dungeon, not every other tile.
- Critical Hits Mechanic, Defense, and Screens: When your attacks score Critical Hits, they ignore the damage reduction of the moves Light Screen, Reflect, Aurora Veil, and similar. The additional dice from Critical Hits are added after the target's (Special) Defense is applied.
- Knock Off Move: Added the effect 'If the target of this move is holding an item, add 2 dice to this move's damage pool.' (Accessories do not count for this effect)
- Howl Move: This move affects all allies.
- Rapid Spin Move: Added the effect 'The user gets +1 Dexterity.' This move is also 2 Power now.
- Defog Move: This move also clears Terrains in addition to its other effects.
- Huge/Pure Power Ability: Changed to 'the user gets +1 Strength'
- Natural HP Healing: You recover 1 HP every time you move to a new tile in a mystery dungeon
- Luck Dice and Accuracy Pools: if a move's Accuracy Pool would be reduced to exactly 0, the move will simply fail. If the accuracy pool would be reduced to a negative number, a Luck Die will be rolled instead. Players may also request Luck Dice to be rolled instead of the move failing if an Accuracy Pool would be reduced to exactly 0 when they are giving their orders for the Round.
- Bug Bite/Pluck Move: The move can consume any consumable item that the target is holding or that is in their bag (selected at random if there are multiple viable targets. This includes but is not limited to Apples, Seeds, Berries, Elixirs, Gummis, etc.
- Life Dew Move: Acc: Dexterity + Survival + Nature, Targets: Spread move that targets allies, Eff: Restores 1 HP at the end of the round for 4 rounds.
Rules Clarifications
- Item Usage: Healing Items (HP, status, etc) are usable at the end of each set of Turns in a Round, and can be used up to twice per Round as a free action. Items with other kinds of effects (Violent Seed, Orbs, etc.) typically take an action to use. Healing Items can also be used in exchange for one of your actions for the Round. Held Item Swapping is also allowed if the item is readily available, and takes an action. Action costs for the Round are calculated as normal, but only affect items that require a roll. If there are items on the ground that you wish to pick up during combat, you may spend an action to do so.
Other
- Natures exist in this game (Page 40 of the corebook), but are optional to use. You don't have to assign your character a Nature if you do not wish to.
And that should do it for the pre-game debrief! I hope everyone's excited to get started, because I know I am! If you have any questions, feel free to ask them in this Meta Thread or PM me.
Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows will begin once I either have at least 4 players participating or it is Tuesday, April 7th, 2020 (whichever comes first)!
3/29/2020: Posted the Meta Thread for Primal Shadows and started character creation!
4/6/2020: Posted the Game and Jukebox Threads. Added Knock Off, Howl, Rapid Spin, Defog, and additional Crit rules to the houserules section.
4/7/2020: Started the game! First post is here!
4/18/2020: Added Natural HP Healing and Pure/Huge Power to the houserules section. Also added a clarification on Item Usage to the Rules Clarifications section.
1/13/2021: Formally added a new rule regarding Luck Dice and Accuracy Pools. Also added an additional rule for Bug Bite and Pluck, formally added Life Dew to the house rules, and added the clarification on picking up items from the ground during combat to the Item Usage section of Rules Clarifications.
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Dragonstrike - 03-29-2020
@Lord Windos, @PhantomUnderYourDesk, and @Spiritmon, I've sent all of you PMs with relevant information you'll need for your character creation. You've got free reign to make copies of the provided character sheet and edit them in preparation for the game.
As always, I'll be available to answer questions if needed.
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Spiritmon - 03-29-2020
Oh yeah baby! We back in action! (Soon, but still good). And the information you sent via PM is amazing! It's even came out better than I could imagine! Thanks Dragonstrike you are the best 
I have a few questions: It is possible to me balance my char to have at least 3 in logic and 3 in Instincts? And how much the score it would begin to affect each other?
Also, according to the MD book, a player can enter the Primal State when they want. And user HP fully restored and a bonus dice based in the Instict stat. Can you confirm that?
And finally: Kee, Karen and Kogeki would still remember each other, or they're memories disappear too?
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Dragonstrike - 03-29-2020
(03-29-2020, 06:33 PM)Spiritmon Wrote: Oh yeah baby! We back in action! (Soon, but still good). And the information you sent via PM is amazing! It's even came out better than I could imagine! Thanks Dragonstrike you are the best 
I have a few questions: It is possible to me balance my char to have at least 3 in logic and 3 in Instincts? And how much the score it would begin to affect each other?
Also, according to the MD book, a player can enter the Primal State when they want. And user HP fully restored and a bonus dice based in the Instict stat. Can you confirm that?
And finally: Kee, Karen and Kogeki would still remember each other, or they're memories disappear too?
Glad you liked what I came up with!
Starting Logic and Instinct scores are 1 in one stat, 2 in the other (your choice which is which), no exceptions. Those two stats are very important to the mechanics of how the game will run. They can both be increased during the course of the game, but it's not meant to be easy, and it'll probably take a good chunk of the game to get both of them to respectable levels since they can both decrease when other stats increase (at least, that's the intention).
Primal State can usually only be triggered when you faint (or in other extremely distressing and dangerous situations). It's partially a penalty for fainting, but also partially a way for you to not lose the game very, very quickly if the RNG decides you're going to have a bad day. Think of it as a last resort that you should avoid the use of unless absolutely necessary.
Kee, Karen, and Kogeki will be able to recognize each other once they've identified who they are, but how they know each other will be unclear IC at first due to their memory loss.
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Spiritmon - 03-29-2020
(03-29-2020, 06:45 PM)Dragonstrike Wrote: Glad you liked what I came up with!
Starting Logic and Instinct scores are 1 in one stat, 2 in the other (your choice which is which), no exceptions. Those two stats are very important to the mechanics of how the game will run. They can both be increased during the course of the game, but it's not meant to be easy, and it'll probably take a good chunk of the game to get both of them to respectable levels since they can both decrease when other stats increase (at least, that's the intention).
Primal State can usually only be triggered when you faint. It's partially a penalty for fainting, but also partially a way for you to not lose the game very, very quickly if the RNG decides you're going to have a bad day. Think of it as a last resort that you should avoid the use of unless absolutely necessary.
Kee, Karen, and Kogeki will be able to recognize each other once they've identified who they are, but how they know each other will be unclear IC at first due to their memory loss.
Wait a minute. Itsnt a bit...unfair? Because if we faint, we loose logic. And if we have 1 in Logic, we will automatic loose. I do hope we at least have a initial good chunk of XP to increase our Logic and Insticts stats to both be at least in 3. I do hope at least we can have that balance, since 3 in both to keep balance. And to make Kogeki use at least Moves of 20 XP cost.
At least we can buy permanent moves, so thats something.
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Dragonstrike - 03-29-2020
(03-29-2020, 08:54 PM)Spiritmon Wrote: Wait a minute. Itsnt a bit...unfair? Because if we faint, we loose logic. And if we have 1 in Logic, we will automatic loose. I do hope we at least have a initial good chunk of XP to increase our Logic and Insticts stats to both be at least in 3. I do hope at least we can have that balance, since 3 in both to keep balance. And to make Kogeki use at least Moves of 20 XP cost.
At least we can buy permanent moves, so thats something.
I gotta remain firm on the starting values for Logic and Instinct. One of them is 1, and the other is 2. Up to you whether you want a few more moves to begin with or added security/more human memories. You can work on increasing the values of both stats during the course of the game. Whether it's unfair or not, it'll certainly add to the story's drama, which is a big focus of Pokerole in general.
Note: If you have 0 Primal, you won't lose any Logic when you faint. Then it goes up to 1 afterwards, however, and that's when you'd have to be more careful of fainting.
I'm well aware that you guys are super vulnerable if you choose to go with the 1 Logic and 2 Instinct route (and you're also rather vulnerable if you do it the other way around, but for different reasons), and I'll be attempting to balance early game content accordingly so that the game doesn't immediately end for your characters before their journey has even begun. I'm not a GM that's out to beat my players. I'm here to tell a story with your help, and tell a story I shall! You guys may be starting out rather weak and at risk, but persevere, and you can work on rising above these humble and frail beginnings!
Carrying Reviver Seeds is also a good way to avoid triggering the Primal State when you faint.
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Lord Windos - 03-29-2020
(03-29-2020, 05:44 PM)Dragonstrike Wrote: @Lord Windos, @PhantomUnderYourDesk, and @Spiritmon, I've sent all of you PMs with relevant information you'll need for your character creation. You've got free reign to make copies of the provided character sheet and edit them in preparation for the game.
As always, I'll be available to answer questions if needed.
Welly well well, what wonderful and DELIGHTFUL surprise! My, am I glad I checked the forums out before I completely hit the hay, ha ha ha ha ha! This is just may just be the heralding of the start to a brand new adventure, but that ain't stopping me from getting PUMPED and excited for it!!!
Since you're accepting questions, though, I got a few for you:
- Abilities: Do our Pokemon Characters have access to all of them like PMD RB and PMD EoTDS, or is it just one Ability only per day like a hybrid of the remake PMD RB and the system for Ability Changing in Pokerole?
- IQ: Since I didn't see it listed in the launch post listings, I presume you had to nix it, or that it'll be some later element you'll introduce once the game goes underway?
- XP Rates: How are you going to handle that throughout the campaign? Because due to the OODLES of Stats and other stuff we need to buy with it (and potentially keep buying, in the case of those Instinctual Stats....), giving us a paltry amount of XP per Fight is going to be the proverbal shackle around our necks throughout the whole campaign. And when Fainting can result in character deletion in most practical cases and the only ways to counter act that are spending EXOBERANT amounts of XP on managing constantly fluctuating states.....
- From what I read on the Instinctual Attributes, it never said anything about Logic decreasing when Instinct is raised, right? If that's the case, then pretty much everyone should raise that stat to 4 or 5 first before going after Logic and spending ALL the money on Revivers/Healing Items to prevent that last Logic point from going up in smoke before you start raising it, or just ignore Instinct forever until you max out Logic first, as otherwise you'll be wasting a LOT of experience trying to balance them mates. Sure, Instinct will go to 0 in the process, but its better to pay that extra 100 XP + 150 XP cost to get it back to Base and to 5 of that than who knows how much more XP if you constantly try to juggle Logic, Instinct, and Feral management....
- Speaking of Items, will their be Gingsings, Attribute Drinks, and other Items that can help along with raising Stats ? Because again, raising a character without a little help in that department or a LOT of XP is going to be a nightmarish slog....
That should all right now, so grace me with your wisdom DMate!
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Dragonstrike - 03-29-2020
(03-29-2020, 09:40 PM)Lord Windos Wrote: Welly well well, what wonderful and DELIGHTFUL surprise! My, am I glad I checked the forums out before I completely hit the hay, ha ha ha ha ha! This is just may just be the heralding of the start to a brand new adventure, but that ain't stopping me from getting PUMPED and excited for it!!!
Since you're accepting questions, though, I got a few for you:
- Abilities: Do our Pokemon Characters have access to all of them like PMD RB and PMD EoTDS, or is it just one Ability only per day like a hybrid of the remake PMD RB and the system for Ability Changing in Pokerole?
- IQ: Since I didn't see it listed in the launch post listings, I presume you had to nix it, or that it'll be some later element you'll introduce once the game goes underway?
- XP Rates: How are you going to handle that throughout the campaign? Because due to the OODLES of Stats and other stuff we need to buy with it (and potentially keep buying, in the case of those Instinctual Stats....), giving us a paltry amount of XP per Fight is going to be the proverbal shackle around our necks throughout the whole campaign. And when Fainting can result in character deletion in most practical cases and the only ways to counter act that are spending EXOBERANT amounts of XP on managing constantly fluctuating states.....
- From what I read on the Instinctual Attributes, it never said anything about Logic decreasing when Instinct is raised, right? If that's the case, then pretty much everyone should raise that stat to 4 or 5 first before going after Logic and spending ALL the money on Revivers/Healing Items to prevent that last Logic point from going up in smoke before you start raising it, or just ignore Instinct forever until you max out Logic first, as otherwise you'll be wasting a LOT of experience trying to balance them mates. Sure, Instinct will go to 0 in the process, but its better to pay that extra 100 XP + 150 XP cost to get it back to Base and to 5 of that than who knows how much more XP if you constantly try to juggle Logic, Instinct, and Feral management....
- Speaking of Items, will their be Gingsings, Attribute Drinks, and other Items that can help along with raising Stats ? Because again, raising a character without a little help in that department or a LOT of XP is going to be a nightmarish slog....
That should all right now, so grace me with your wisdom DMate!
- Abilities will be 'pick one at the start of the day from your available ones', like in MCM.
- Expect Gummis to show up at a later point in the game. However, they won't be granting IQ points. They're going to work a bit differently.
- XP won't be split this time around, instead being fixed values like how you handled it in CCV so that everyone has more exp to spend than they would otherwise. Expect my exp rates to differ, however.
- Correct! Logic does not decrease when Instinct increases! If it did, it'd be impossible to max out any stats. Keep in mind, however, that your human memories are going to be very important for anything related to your character's backstory.
- Vitamins are present in the PMD universe, but they're usually rather rare.
--------------------------------------
Some additional notes:
Remember I can also award points in the Instinctual Stats based on your roleplay, and those don't cost a single point of exp when I do (though the rate you gain those points is gonna slow down significantly the higher the stats are already due to their rather large effects). Good roleplay based on your stats is an important part of this game, and the more good roleplaying you do, the more likely it is that I'll reward it (eventually).
You may also want to reserve your judgements on the difficulty of the game until we've started playing it. I know the L/I/P stats are scary sounding on paper, but that's why I'm adjusting the difficulty of the game accordingly.
There may also be other things that are worth spending money on besides items. I'm putting a heavy emphasis on roleplaying in this game, not just combat.
---------------------------------------
TLDR; It may be a lot of mechanics to worry about, but if you actively participate in the game and have fun with it, I'm reasonably certain that everything will work out as I hope it will.
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Lord Windos - 03-29-2020
Err....I'm not too sure I can get into the sort of heavy RPing you want with my character outside of combat or being a foil to other characters, mate, so I wouldn't expect too much out of me right out of the gate. I know exactly the sort of play I am for the most part (The Fighter/ Supporting Cast Member) , so going outside that will be rather....rough on me for awhile.
The reason I'm paying particular attention to Institual Stats is because they're another 'Meter' gameplay element we potentially have to constantly monitor or pray that you're feeling generous when we need the points the most. The only way we have consistent and absolute control over those Stats - and really almost anything about our Pokemon intrinsically - is by spending XP to modulate them, and since that with I.Ss that's potentially a perpetual problem to manage (Especially if you give Logic Points if we don't want them yet) .....I think my caution is a little warranted until I get my feet wet with your campaign. It's not going to paralyze me or ruin it (Heck, I'm likely to have more fun because of those stats, given the way my chara is!), but I find paranioa and concern about odds in a Dice Game to be a very healthy thing indeed! Its all fun and games until you get snake eyes 5 times in a row, after all....
RE: [Meta Thread] Pokerole Mystery Dungeon: Primal Shadows - Dragonstrike - 03-29-2020
I'm sure it'll be fine, Windos. I'm doing my best to give everyone a role in this story, regardless of their characters' origins. There'll be a time and place for good roleplay for everyone, even if it isn't right away, as that's the nature of the game we're playing. Participation and good roleplay can mean many different things in the context of the game, after all.
I may not always decrease your character's Instinct when Logic increases. Depends on the circumstances behind why I'm awarding the Logic point.
Caution is fine since it's a new mechanic, but let's also try not to start a long debate about something we haven't even used yet. I'll do my best to make sure the introduction of the mechanic isn't intrusive at the start of the game. Just need ya to have a little faith that I'm doing my best to balance everything appropriately.
|