[Meta thread] Iron's PokeRole Adventure: The Skull Ruins

[Iron]

Some of what Ventus knows from his education is not accurate for Creshire, so that might explain his Knowledge score.



So it's not nearly as powerful as being psychic. Plus, you're a human - Pokemon will always be better than you at many, many things just by their "magical" or powerful nature. Someone with 5 insight would be as good as Earth's greatest psychologist or inspired writer - someone with 6 would start being a bit supernatural about it.

As for using Insight on a player, I will use much the same stance as I use in D&D:
The dice may say that you see no signs of a bluff, but the DM doesn't control the player, so you'll believe or disbelieve as you will.
BUT it's important to separate character knowledge from player knowledge, and Ventus can't read minds (even Ralts can only sense emotions right now). So I don't think it's reasonable for Ventus to believe Vincent encountered more Deyo, especially since they won't be the biggest thing on Vincent's mind when he gets back.