[Meta thread] Lord Windos' PokeRole Adventure : Celadon City Vandels

[Dragonstrike]

Win win in my book, so why did they not accept such a compromise......?

Let me just answer this real quick because that seems to be the only thing your confused about.

It was part of Arial's test.

Reiner didn't accept the compromise, but he never rejected it either.  He just stared, stayed completely silent, and left the decision to Arial.