[Meta Thread] Dragonstrike's Pokerole Test Game: Mount Coronet Mystery

[Lord Windos]

It shouldn't matter whether you defend yourself by clashing a physical move with a special one or vice versa, because why should it? I can't see a general reason for that, may depend on the scenario however (Like, clashing a Hurricane with a Tackle? Good luck trying.)

Yeah, if a Clash doesn't seem feasible to me, it just won't work, and I'll say as such in the meta thread before rolling anything.  Fire Blast vs Water Gun, for example?  I think the Fire Blast wins out in that scenario, even though it's at a type disadvantage.

If that's the case, that makes me not want to use Clash even more, as you're going to apply logic/reason to what should be a purely mechanical way of avoiding damage to make it objectively worse, what's the point of using it over Evasion, which works against everything but AoE and Contest Roll Moves? I'm sorry mate, but that's what I see such a decision as, and I can't honestly put my heart into supporting it.

SO there's a split vote now, but since you favored Option B), that's likely going into effect in the end, much to my displeasure as it currently stand. Oh well, I'll just have to come up with ways to screw over Evasion users.