[Meta Thread] Dragonstrike's Pokerole Test Game: Mount Coronet Mystery

[Dragonstrike]

Spoiler

I don't like the fact that Weathers are realism based (And very disappointed you went this route, mate) or you're essentially forcing me to make a blind decision instead of outright saying Drought will work or not in the Temple, but as you quoted me saying, I'll live with it. 

Since you specifically said Abilities had to be decided before the first Encounter was started, but Ran is currently outside the Temple and therefore has not yet started his First Encounter, he'll also has them if Weather like Harsh Sunlight works inside the ancient place. If he says no or doesn't know, then Brigid's Ability will be White Smoke, as I rather have an Ability that I know will work all the time than gamble with one that won't.

This is one of the big reasons why I don't like more realistic interpretations of Game Moves/Mechanics that didn't have them in the first place: they imposed arbitrary restrictions that make certain Moves/Abilities outright useless, which ain't fun to play around or with. If it's for the shake of balance I can abide by restrictions if they're both necessary and reasonable, but otherwise I prefer a more 'laissez faire' approach to mechanics (IE: Just letting things work, regardless if it would make logical sense or not).It logic/realism is to be used with game mechanics, it should be either be used to make things better, or as a sorta challenge/consideration to deal with that does not outright prevent you from using said mechanics (Like Earthquake in a cave: you can still use it, but it's not a terribly good idea unless you're desperate). Preventing most Weather from working outright indoors.....I don't really consider that a challenge so much as an annoyance.

Think about the context a little instead of complaining about it, please.  Just because I'm implementing realism, it doesn't mean I can't have unrealistic mechanics that border on the supernatural.